Case-Mate was founded to meet the growing demand for stylish phone cases. The company understood that phone cases go beyond just offering protection. By making them colorful and stylish, it allows phone users to personalize their devices.

The company has been using high-quality materials to create amazing phone cases that last ages. It has even received a BBB rating of A+. That’s proof that it’s doing the right things so far.

Casetify, on the other hand, was created in 2011. It has had better success at marketing itself around the world. Multiple celebrities like Taylor Swift have been spotted with Casetify phone cases.

The company claims to create indestructible cases, and that’s one of the things we will be investigating today. Ready to see how the two compare with each other? Let’s get down to business.

The product range and variety goes beyond simple phone cases. The more the options, the better. Here’s how the two fared.

Case-Mate works with a wide variety of cases for Android and iOS devices. You can find cases for Apple phones ranging from iPhone 13, 14, 15, and other earlier versions. The entire Samsung Galaxy line is supported. That includes the Flip5 and the Fold5, among many others.

Google Pixel cases can also be found in varying designs and sizes. Other major brands with cases include Motorola and LG.

Besides phone cases, Case-Mate also offers screen and lens protectors for all brands of phones. You can even combine specific cases with screen protectors that match to give your device a unique look.

Other products you can buy from the Case-Mate online store include Magsafes, power banks, phone straps, pouches, etc. In short, Case-Mate is a one-stop shop for everything related to smart devices.

Casetify cases are more stylish. While it has phone cases for all devices, it makes them unique by adding colorful artwork. Think of all the comic or anime-based artwork you see on phone cases. There’s a high possibility that the case is from Casetify.

Notable phone brands with supported cases here include Apple, Samsung, and Google. For Apple, you can find cases for iPhone 15, 14, and 13 all the way to iPhone 7. Other Apple products with varying protective cases include AirPods, iPads, MacBooks, Apple Watches, etc.

For Samsung, Casetify has stocked accessories for the Galaxy S and Galaxy Z series of devices. On top of this, there’s extensive support for Galaxy Buds. Google Pixel users are also well represented, as there are phone cases for all Pixel devices.

Verdict: When it comes to the range of products, both of these companies tie. Case-Mate and Casetify cover all the major phone brands like Apple, Samsung, LG, and Google Pixel. But if you want accessories beyond smartphones, Case-Mate has the upper hand.

Allowing users to create the cases they want is important. So let’s see how flexible these two are in this area.

Case-Mate combines many different designs to create unique phone cases. Case-Mate makes sure there’s something for everyone. It offers classic leather finishes all the way to striking and colorful patterns that make your phone stand out.

Case-Mate’s varied material selection is one of its advantages. Genuine leather and durable polycarbonate are among the options available to users. This diversity meets the practical needs of many users while also enhancing the aesthetic appeal.

On top of the aesthetic appeal, these cases are very hardy. They can protect your device from physical damage when it hits the floor.

Customization options are also boundless with Case-Mate. The brand even works with artists and other designers to create customized cases. You can have a phone case made to your exact liking.

Occasionally, Case-Mate creates limited edition designs that can only be bought for a specific duration of time.

Casetify is more flexible than Case-Mate in design variations and customizations. The platform even allows users to upload their own images to the site so they can create unique cases.

The images could be their own or artwork they have created or bought. This is the level of customization that Case-Mate can’t match. But like Case-Mate, Casetify also works with different artists to make customized cases.

The biggest advantage of this is that it gives a platform to the artists. On top of getting paid for their work, they’re exposed to a bigger audience. These collaborations drive the phone case prices further down, making them accessible to more people.

Verdict: Casetify is better than Case-Mate when it comes to designs and customizations. While both companies outsource designs to third-party artists, Casetify takes a bolder approach. Their cases are more colorful and stylish.

Nobody wants to keep replacing their cases every few months. So durability and ability to protect the phone is important for many users. Let’s dig further.

The main reason why people get phone cases is to provide protection to their devices. Smartphones are fragile, and the cost of replacing screens in high-end models is exorbitant. So here, materials matter.

Casetify also uses TPU plus a blend of other materials to give their cases durability with maximum protection. So, you’ll always get the right balance between flexibility and sturdiness. But while Casetify doesn’t boast of any proprietary grip technology, it still does a good job of preventing slipping.

The outer layers of the cases come with multi-layered construction with an extra hard outer shell that absorbs shock. The layer also features well-placed grooves that increase the grip to stop accidental drops.

Like Case-Mate, you also get a scratch-resistant case. Casetify adds a layer of coatings that not only stop scratches but also make them invisible unless you really squint. When you combine the colorful artwork common with Casetify cases, no one will notice the scratches.

Verdict: While both brands provide protection against falls, scratches, and cracks, Case-Mate is better. The proprietary ShockGrip technology makes things easier for the user.

When it comes to pricing, it all comes down to individual cases. The final price is determined by the size of the case as well as the customizations requested. However, there are still some slight differences in shipping fees and item returns.

Case-Mate markets itself as a high-end brand, and the overall prices reflect this accurately. Most of the cases are typically more expensive compared to other competitors like Casetify.

The reason for this may be the level of customizations needed and the use of proprietary tech like ShockGrip.

While this may deter some buyers, Case-Mate’s dedication to quality has built a devoted fanbase. As for discounts, Case-Mate customers get occasional offers and promotions. These increase during major events like Black Friday.

The discounts are usually based on percentages, or you may get to Buy-One-Get-One-Free. The shipping fees vary depending on the distance.

Additionally, you may be offered free shipping for certain orders. For those who want to expedite their shipping, an extra charge is necessary.

Case-Mate’s return policy takes 30 days from the date of purchase. A refund is subject to a detailed check of the product to ensure that the damage is from production.

The payment options available for Case-Mate include major debit and credit cards like Visa, American Express, Discover, and Mastercard. You can also check out with BitPay, PayPal, or Klarna.

Casetify’s pricing is more flexible and affordable than Case-Mate’s. The online shop is stocked with budget-friendly options without compromising quality. At the same time, there are luxurious options for people who don’t mind spending more on a case.

The platform also has amazing discounts and promotions throughout the year. You can take advantage of flash sales or holiday events. Another area where Casetify beats Case-Mate is that it offers discounts to students.

People can also earn amazing discounts by referring other people to the site. Casetify also provides free standard shipping on certain amounts of orders. But it’s significantly cheaper than Case-Mate.

The return policy is only enforceable when done within 30 days. The product has to be returned without extra damage for a refund or exchange to be made.

The payment options available on Casetify include Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Apple Pay.

Verdict: Casetify is cheaper overall than Case-Mate. Both brands offer discounts and promotions, but Casetify has better incentives. It also caters to both ends of the financial spectrum.

Customer Reviews are the backbone of online shopping. You’re likely to get unfiltered truths about a product when you check out reviews. Let’s see how these two fared in the court of public opinion.

Here are the main Case-Mate pros and cons.

• Compatible with a wide range of smart devices
• Uses durable construction materials
• Has ShockGrip technology for extra safety
• Collaborates with independent artists

• Expensive
• Not as flexible with customizations
• Low user reviews and ratings

Here are the notable Casetify pros and cons.

• Offers more customizable design options
• Is cheaper with flexible prices
• Positive user reviews
• Works with a wide range of devices
• The cases are scratch-resistant

• Lacks proprietary protection tech like Case-Mate
• Most of its cases can be slippery

Casetify is the winner.

It has better design and customizations, more affordable prices, and better customer reviews.

Case-Mate, on the other hand, is more durable and offers state-of-the-art protection. It has a specific niche of customers.

Both brands have a wide range of products though. You can go with the one that matches your needs.

Tom Clayton

Tom loves to write on technology, e-commerce & internet marketing. I started my first e-commerce company in college, designing and selling t-shirts for my campus bar crawl using print-on-demand. Having successfully established multiple 6 & 7-figure e-commerce businesses (in women’s fashion and hiking gear), I think I can share a tip or 2 to help you succeed.